THESIS STATEMENT LIZZIE BORDEN

Lizzie Borden grew a well-bred girl, went to church, knew knitting, sewing, catching fish. Actually, considering the extreme duress she was under, I found much of what she said articulate, thoughtful, and well-spoken. If Lizzie Borden had opportunity, likewise did Bridget during her various housecleaning rounds that day upstairs and downstairs. This is because you had no reason to remember relatively mundane activities. Bridget was indeed a stranger, hired as a servant. And that same fixation against Ms. I write this to exonerate Lizzie Borden in the public eye.

Of course, prosecutors and judges must make a judgment call in every case, however in my judgment there was just no compelling reason due to lack of evidence to indict her. Fortunately, justice never really obtained in any murder case prevailed…not for the victims, but for Lizbeth Borden, when she was pronounced not guilty on June 20, The process went 10 days and Lizzie was acquitted. She came running and saw the body of her master. There is no way truth can be derived from the virtual void of evidence cited. He seems a man more controlled by emotionalism than logic or rationality.

Why make an assumption that only one woman was capable of such rage?

thesis statement lizzie borden

Consider the culprit being an intruder, unbeknownst by either of the two women, who has murdered Abby and lays in wait for escape. Inquest Testimony Supports Her Innocence Thus, after having read that transcript, knowing the circumstances upon which she was interrogated, I find the few minor inconsistencies in her answers a likely and understandable result of the stress she was under, as well as giving the ring of truth to her answers.

Lizzie Borden Exonerated – my thesis | Blog of Christine Smith

Lizzie Borden, despite the distance between herself and Abby, maintained a good relationship with lizzir father. The difference, strange and thus incomprehensible to emotionally controlled people, makes us unemotional when others in same situation would become wild in their physical and emotional demeanor.

When she was two years old, her mother died. It would require a treatise, if not a book, to systematically address the many oft repeated claims of evidence frequently cited in the case statemen her, and it is neither I choose to write at this time. Audio available at end of thesis below.

Suppressed anger is often characteristic of violence exhibited attack upon the faces of victims, while as it has been seen that those with conflicted feelings of relationship liazie the victim often results in victim bodies which are covered as to show respect for the deceased — even though the perpetrator committed the killing — not mutilation. The same day, a brother of the first wife of Mr. Of course, prosecutors and judges must make a judgment call in every case, however in my judgment there was just no compelling reason due to lack of evidence to indict her.

  DISSERTATION JURIDIQUE ETAT UNITAIRE ET ETAT FEDERAL

It is interesting to note that murders by maids is not a far-fetched fictional scenario, but one with a significant number of cases which illustrate it is not at all unprecedented…indeed it is unusual but not uncommon.

I was impressed by her relative composure and lack of emotionalism the very attributes some listening to her apparently found disturbingand I identify with the personality and qualities of mind norden evinced. The strangest thing about this case is that she is the only suspect.

Lizzie Borden Research Paper

Only one motive not the reason for its formation is clear in the Borden murders: Click here to read more about custom research papers here! Objectivity, in this case, in my opinion, would have necessitated just as much scrutiny on the other woman in the house that day, as well as also considering the possibility of an outside intruder.

The inquest testimony was not allowed into trial due to the absence of her lawyer and the circumstances of pressure placed upon her. Lizzie herself after a light food poisoning felt bad.

Reading the inquest, I interpret him as an attorney with a big ego, one who seems to have no intellectual appreciation for a woman who answers his repetitive annoying and to me, often nonsensical pedantic questioning so relatively consistently despite his attempts seemingly to provoke her into emotionalism; it is as if he cannot understand or does not want to understand logical, rational answers.

The question bears asking and pondering: Her sister Emma lived with her, but, as told by their neighbors, the sisters had a quarrel, and Emma left Lizzie. Such generosity as shown to many in her will was characteristic of her entire life, as she was it was later learned responsible for years of numerous anonymous deliveries of of food and other provisions including college scholarships for the residents of Fall River who were in need.

  ULU DISSERTATION BINDING

Putting motive evaluation aside for a moment as it is but suppositionlogically, if one accepts Lizzie Borden had opportunity, likewise did Sullivan. On August 4thAndrew and Sarah Borden were found dead in their home. Borden, John Morse, who stayed at their house for a few days left. The evil of a woman takes a very different form of maliciousness and cruelty and thus a different form of vile manifestation particularly when directed against family members including their children.

Never did he take the ring from his hand she had given him as a gift. She had opportunity consider her cleaning activities, never discovering the body of Abby, and her rest time during which time Lizzy indicates she was in the barn and her father lay vulnerable in the downstairs room.

Thus, after having read that transcript, knowing the circumstances upon which she was interrogated, I find the few minor inconsistencies in her answers a likely and understandable result of the stress she was under, as well as giving the ring of truth to her answers.

Reading the inquest, I interpret him as an attorney with a big ego, one who seems to have no intellectual appreciation for a woman who answers his repetitive annoying and to me, often nonsensical pedantic questioning so relatively consistently despite his attempts seemingly to provoke her into emotionalism; it is as if he cannot understand or does not want to understand logical, rational answers.

She sold the old house and bought a new one.

Actually, considering the extreme duress she was under, I found much of what she said articulate, thoughtful, and well-spoken. Comment Name Email Website. Her father remarried to Abby Gray in Indeed, her own sister, maintained belief in her innocence, and they made a life together in a home for several years after the trial until they went their separate ways. In my opinion, the severe questioning, and her earnest answers sans counsel, was a negative reflection upon Hosea M.

thesis statement lizzie borden